All EOS blogs All Spain blogs  Start your own blog Start your own blog 

Mac's Poll - Let's Vote

Curious to know what the general opinion is? Cast your vote and let's see!!

POLL : Speaking Spanish delays dementia! - How well do you speak?
Thursday, January 31, 2013 @ 5:26 PM

 

 381 unique participants - 15 comments. first week of voting

Surprising result ! According to the poll,  62,17% of the participants can speak atleast enough Spanish to get by and be understood. 

 

George Orwell wrote in 1938: "The only way I could get along was to carry everywhere a small dictionary which I whipped out of my pocket at moments of crisis. But I would sooner be a foreigner in Spain than in most countries. How easy it is to make friends in Spain!"

 More than 70 years after the publication of Homage to Catalonia, a million of Orwell's fellow countrymen have followed his lead, eventhough many have now returned due to the crisis. The British are the largest contingent of foreigners in Spain and 2% of the population. But does that 2% of the population speak Spanish? 

 

These are a few views of expat journalists, expat politicians and locals on the subject:

 

"Brits tends to live in a bubble. With more and more information available in English, there's less reason to learn Spanish and, as a consequence, less opportunity to understand the local culture. Many residents speak no more than 10 Spanish words in an average week – usually restaurant Spanish – and they pride themselves on 'getting by'.”

 "By moving to Spain, most have opted out of the rat race, substituting social responsibility for social activity within the numerous Brit clubs, amateur theatre and charity groups that have mushroomed over the entire Costa Blanca."

 "It's difficult. I try to practise my Spanish but people come back to me in English."

"British people do not seem to integrate terribly well.They are very good at societies, book clubs, social organisations of different kinds but, in general, they seem to associate with themselves more often with other expats.”

 

 

"In my personal experience, many Britons seem to have many things to complain about – the madness of the property market and rental prices, the even madder madness of red tape and paperwork when they need to deal with government offices and funcionarios. This is partly due to the culture shock and the contrast between the Anglo-Saxon and Latin mentalities but it does make some things difficult when it comes to integration and learning the language."

 

 

Recent research has shown,  using Spanish in everyday situations and sticking to regular classes can help prevent or delay the onset of Alzheimer's disease, say doctors.

Learning a foreign language could put back the first signs of dementia by at least five years,

Expatriates in Spain are at a particular advantage, since those who regularly use the language they have learnt are even more likely to fight off Alzheimer's than those who have merely studied one and let it lay dormant. Whilst crosswords, sudokus and other 'thinking' puzzles have long been lauded as a tool for fighting off memory loss and confusion in old age, experts believe that those who speak two or more languages have even more chance of retaining their mental faculties.

They say learning a language is a more powerful type of mental exercise, and builds up a bank of 'spare' brainpower which helps the mind to keep working for longer and more effectively, slowing down the debilitating effects of Alzheimer's.

Medics behind the research, which took place at York University in Toronto, Canada, say this is rather like keeping a spare battery for your mobile phone or an emergency tank of petrol in your car.

"It means your brain can keep going for longer because there is more in the safety tank," they say.

The part of the brain that controls memory, decision-making, reasoning and expressing oneself in words is made stronger, more flexible and more resistant to damage by learning and using a foreign language.

Doctors claim the sooner a person starts to learn a language, the more beneficial it is for slowing down the process of dementia and age-related confusion.

Researchers found that the average Alzheimer's sufferer began to see the early symptoms of their condition in their mid-70s, or younger, where they only spoke one language.

But those who spoke two or more languages - or were actively learning one - tended to be in their 80s before they were diagnosed with dementia.

Additionally, the process of the mind breaking down - including loss of short-term memory - took hold much more rapidly in monolingual patients.

However, they warn that learning a language will not actually prevent Alzheimer's - it will simply slow down the associated mental deterioration and stop the condition from manifesting itself for much longer.

 

 

So how well do you speak Spanish? Are you fighting off dementia or have you already gone mad trying to get to grips with it?

 

 

 

Please participate, it will be interesting to see how many of the memebers of  Eye on Spain, actually get by in Spanish. Please leave a comment and let us know how your learning experience was and how you are getting on!

 

 

Sources : Costa News / The Guardian



Like 0




18 Comments


Davespain said:
Friday, February 1, 2013 @ 9:19 AM

It all makes sense to me. Im staggered by how many expats just cant be bothered to even try. I would say that in my experience 95% of UK expats living in Spain have next to no knowledge of real spanish - apart from the usual bar and drink words. It is so embarrassing - it is also bad manners on their parts too. Its probably the biggest factor in causing problems for themselves - alck of communication. I often wonder how many of these people moaned in the UK when the first influx of asians came over in the 60s and found it hard to communicate. It gives the Brits, im Spanish eyes, a reputation for rudeness and stupidity.


eggcup said:
Friday, February 1, 2013 @ 3:16 PM

Yes, it is very debilitating. Our Spanish husband and wife lawyer team come to the UK every year and he does all the talking and she says people look at her as though she's an imbecile and she just has to grin and nod. On the other side, a friend of ours who was extremely witty and great with the banter came to live in Spain, made minimal effort and he, too, appeared to the Spanish as a dim-witted person. It also meant that he could not integrate in any meaningful way.
It is presumably a lot easier if you go to an area with lots of expats, so I'd recommend that for anyone who feels they will never be able and/or willing to get to grips with the language.


Deecoco said:
Saturday, February 2, 2013 @ 7:37 AM

Yes I do speak enough Spanish to get by.. depending on the circumstances.. anything technical and Im lost.
However understanding it is quite another matter again it depends on the subject content .. I am often able to "fill in the gaps".

I do get a kick out of speaking it and being understood.. but I get more frustrated by the fact that I make the effort and then often the response often comes back in English
Such is life !!!


Neville Shelley said:
Saturday, February 2, 2013 @ 7:44 AM

I have chosen to live and work in Spain and speaking Spanish has become necessary for me. I must admit I have not found it easy and at 62 years of age I must admit it has kept my brain cells going!


George said:
Saturday, February 2, 2013 @ 10:56 AM

I find it difficult to believe the poll results. I live in a small village in inland Spain. There are quite a large number of Brits living in large houses in the surrounding countryside and have done for 10 years or more. Few, if any, integrate with the locals. During their occasional visits to the local bar only english is spoken and they even object if spoken to in spanish. Shopping means a trip to Malaga because english is spoken there. House maintenance is carried out by Brit builders who would not be out of place on a well known TV program. The locals are very dismissive of them and resent not being invited to do work especially in these difficult times.

Although not fluent in spanish I have found my neighbours to be very welcoming because I try to converse in their language and we have many laughs over my mistakes and my abilities improve each week. Their extended families ensure that whatever I need is delivered rapidly and economically.

I would urge all Brits to make the effort instead of complaining that the locals do not talk english.


BigBrenda said:
Saturday, February 2, 2013 @ 11:25 AM

I'm another one who falls into the "can get by" category - I can often "follow" a conversation ok but by the time I've worked out what to say in response someone else has said something and the conversation has moved on.

I live in a small Spanish village and would love to be able to speak more to my fellow inhabitants. I really have tried to learn Spanish but no matter how hard I try, vocabulary seems to go in one ear and out the other. I was useless at French when I was at school and although I am better at Spanish I probably still fall into the useless category.


Norman said:
Saturday, February 2, 2013 @ 11:34 AM

We finally moved to Spain at the end of August and I started at an Arte y Cultura Spanish beginners class by the end of September. Being now 63, it has not been easy and we are still in the early stages but I am surprised that some of my classmates have lived in Spain for more than 5 years. However, it is great that they have decided to try even now. I am starting to use phrases but, as has been said, it is a little dispiriting when the reply is given in English.


Valerie White said:
Saturday, February 2, 2013 @ 12:48 PM

As I live in basically a Spanish community, a village in Lecrin del Valle, and my landlord and landlady are Spanish, I am trying very hard to learn the language. However, I have "fallen by the wayside" lately and really must make a concerted effort. As I am now approaching my 69th birthday, am still finding it somewhat difficult. I can get by but as yet cannot hold a decent conversation in Spanish. All I can say is - must try harder!


Shobhana said:
Saturday, February 2, 2013 @ 2:54 PM

To be honest, I can't imagine why anyone would up and move to Spain without having *some* interest in or willingness to immerse themselves in the local culture. I mean it's the least you'd expect of someone moving to the UK!

Some people learn languages faster than others, but we all have the ability in us. I have made a huge effort to learn Spanish during my visits here by watching Spanish TV, listening to the radio, using online resources and making Spanish penpals to write to and get support from.

My efforts can only ever reward me now and in the long term.



Davespain said:
Saturday, February 2, 2013 @ 4:13 PM

I think the poll looks a little different from what one woud expect for 2 reasons. Firstly, people tend to think they are more profficient than they actaully (simple human nature) but mostly I would imagine that by definition the people who visit this site, and therefor the ones who comment, are probably many of the minority who can be bothered to learn the language. Those who just come to Spain and arent interested in the country, the people, the culture etc probably wouldnt waste their time here when they can be gorging on another plate of fish and chips and a pint of John Smith's.


mac said:
Saturday, February 2, 2013 @ 5:52 PM

Well I am surprised with the result. But to see that the majority get by or can hold a conversation is promising. Certainly from my experience of expats in Spain the majority that I know can't get by although they may think they can. Maybe we should deinfe what "get by" means! :) Only when you really control the language to you start to realise what you've been missing out on.
I speak Spanish fluently but I worked very hard at it the first couple of years. I read in Spanish everyday, I talk in Spanish everyday and I socialise with Spanish everyday. My life isn't so much an "ex-pat" life as I live in a spanish neighborhood and I think there are only a couple of brits in my area, who I don't even know. So it has been total immersion fro me for years and years. I have friends who have been here 8 years and are still struggling, but mainly because they don't go that extra step to learn. They get caught up in their world and time flies by while they are missing out on so much.


Carole said:
Saturday, February 2, 2013 @ 6:22 PM

I arrived in Spain already speaking fluent Italian and having taken a 6 week Spanish course at a language school in Mexico. Although I can read Spanish fluently enough to file my own taxes and read legal documents online, my spoken Spanish is infused with Italian which I spoke at work for 15 years. If I'm stuck for a Spanish verb or vocabulary word, Italian takes over, it's a strong habit to break at 70. But in day to day life in Spain I speak Spanish, no one replies to me in English. But for the record, I'm Yank not a Brit!


Brad said:
Sunday, February 3, 2013 @ 4:25 PM

I teach Spanish in Estepona and most of my students are English. Over the years I've seen many of them "come out of the expat closet" and start participating in life in Spain with Spanish people. I particularly remember one couple who, after having reached an intermediate level in Spanish, had a wonderful experience in a small village in the Serrania de Ronda. Since they were trying to speak Spanish in a small place where was off the main tourist track, they became the central attraction one afternoon in a local bar. The locals invited them to drinks and just chatted with them, possibly surprised by finding a foreign couple who were actually trying to speak Spanish.

I go to Portugal a couple of times every year, so it seems logical to me to learn Portuguese, which I do by practicing with Portuguese friends on Skype. Even if it isn't logical, it's a lot of fun and my experience in Portugal is completely different because of my attempts to speak and understand.

Those who live in Spain and don't try to learn Spanish simply do not know what they are missing.


Tony Canavan said:
Sunday, February 3, 2013 @ 5:17 PM

I am a regular visitor to Spain and I decided when I bought my apartment to try and learn the language. I go to a tutor in Ireland once a week and study some Spanish every day at home. I now have basic Spanish conversation. I hope next year to stay in Spain for a number of months and perhaps join a conversation group. Its not easy and requires much application.I am at the stage now that I am beginning to enjoy it. Listening is difficult but again it is important to listen regularly (in my case to discs). It is a good way to show appreciation for a wonderful country, despite the problems.



Dawn Watkins said:
Monday, February 4, 2013 @ 8:45 AM

I'm constantly surprised - disapointed is probably a better word!- by the lack of effort most English ex-pats put in to learning Spanish and integrating into Spanish culture and society...I feel very sorry for them as they are missing out on so much and won't ever 'get' the real Spain and Spaniards!!


Kathy Price said:
Thursday, February 7, 2013 @ 4:57 PM

I've been in Spain for 10 years, after 5 years in France (I spoke French pretty fluently). My Spanish is now adequate to hold a conversation (at a recent Birthday I was one of 3 Brits in company with 5 Spaniards, and we got along fine!). I'm attending an advanced Spansih class with a native teacher, who is now teaching us Spanish slang! I find it's my grammar that lets me down, as I never learned Spanish verbs like we learnt French at school, ie by chanting them over and over. Perserverance is the key - I only have Spanish TV, and have it on in the background all the time I'm indoors. There are some very interesting documentaries on Channel 2.


Sandra Piddock said:
Saturday, March 9, 2013 @ 8:56 AM

I'm late to the party - too late to vote - but I'll comment anyway. I started to teach myself Spanish as soon as we knew we were buying here, and I got to the 'get by' level, and seemed to stick there.

I'm now going to weekly lessons, and I feel as if I'm learning something every week. It's not expensive - I pay 5 Euro - but it's a very worthwhile investment.


Ron said:
Saturday, March 30, 2013 @ 5:16 AM

I recently discovered ConversationExchange.com. There you can find someone wanting to learn your native language while helping you learn theirs (via Skype). Check it out! I'm doing 10 hours a week learning Castellano (Castilian Spanish) and its idioms.


Leave a comment

You don't have to be registered to leave a comment but it's quicker and easier if you are (and you also can get notified by email when others comment on the post). Please Sign In or Register now.

Name *
Spam protection: 
 
Your comment * (HTML not allowed)

(Items marked * are required)



 

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse you are agreeing to our use of cookies. More information here. x